Statement
The original poster design by J. Paul Verrees was commissioned by the National War Garden Commission during the second world war to promote home gardening and canning as a way to provide food for the troops fighting abroad and increase the chances of winning the war.
J. Paul Verrees' work uses a mode of appeal called 'logos'. Aristotle defines this as being a means of communication where the argument presented makes logical sense.
The brief for this project was to redesign Verrees' poster using two other modes of appeal - pathos and ethos where pathos is about drama, drawing on the emotions and ethos is an ethical mode of appeal, the product or object is often endorsed by a reputable person or company.
Process
My previous posts on this project show the following process (you can click on the link 'Vislang' on the right to see the process in more depth with images):
1. Study of the three modes of appeal: ethos, logos and pathos
2. Find a poster to redesign from given resources
3. Research chosen poster design and post artwork and research
4. Sketch fifteen new design ideas using pathos and fifteen using ethos
5. Choose ten of these thirty designs and make larger more detailed sketches
6. Complete four different samples of ways to render the final piece. I chose pen and ink, pencil, cut paper and marker
7. Choose one final design of each mode of appeal and further iterate out in sketch form paying close attention to hierarchy
8. Select the final design layout from each mode of appeal. We selected the design using the image of the jar with the label, 'You Can Preserve Your Future' for ethos and the 'Grow your own economy' design for pathos
9. Take some initial photographs in different settings and begin making some poster mockups, also ink some further renderings of the pathos poster
10. On seeing the photographs for the canning poster we chose to shoot a few jars in the studio and in addition to the pathos poster design we decided to switch the ink rendering to a magazine article layout.
11. In addition to trying the shots in the studio, I also tried the home pantry, the kitchen and an outdoor garden setting
12. Design five different ways to lay out the article and five different ways to design the poster
13. Choose one final mode of appeal and one design layout. We chose a four page layout of the article. This would communicate the same idea as the original poster but this time using ethos as the mode of appeal - the article is written by the Kansas City Community Gardens
14. Fine tune photography and article layout
15. Print color samples on the Konica
16. Present article on black mount board and in a sample magazine, alongside the original poster design
Final Artifact
This is the final artwork (the original poster is shown below):